Declining or Curtailed? Reading a Belmont County, Ohio Gas Royalty Check
MINERAL RIGHTS & ROYALTIES
What could your mineral rights be worth?
Tell us a little about your interest. Get a free, no-obligation review from Selling My Mineral Rights.
A Belmont County royalty check that pays half what it paid eighteen months ago is telling you something, but not necessarily what you assume. Two very different things shrink a gas check in eastern Ohio, and they point in opposite directions on value. One is the reservoir handing over less gas every month, which is permanent. The other is your operator deciding not to sell at the price on offer, which is not. What your interest is worth depends on which one you are looking at.
Belmont County produces gas and almost nothing else
Belmont is Ohio’s largest gas county and has been for a decade. In the second quarter of 2026 it reported roughly 163.7 billion cubic feet, ahead of Harrison at about 91.9 Bcf and Jefferson at about 87.6 Bcf. The producers filing those volumes include Ascent Resources – Utica LLC, Gulfport Appalachia LLC, Rice Drilling D LLC and Expand Operating LLC.
The annual series, aggregated from Ohio Department of Natural Resources filings, is where it gets interesting:
- 2019: about 930.2 Bcf
- 2021: about 756.1 Bcf
- 2022: about 592.8 Bcf
- 2023: about 612.3 Bcf
- 2024: about 595.8 Bcf
- 2025: about 499.9 Bcf
That is a 46 percent fall from 2019, and a 16 percent fall in 2025 alone. But look at 2023: the county produced about 3 percent more gas than in 2022. A county total is not a decline curve. It is the sum of old wells fading, new wells coming online, and gas that was available but not sold. Your check is the same sum in miniature.
What Belmont does not have is a liquids cushion. Its roughly 989,000 barrels of oil and condensate in 2025 come to about 5.9 Bcf equivalent at the conventional six-to-one ratio — around 1.2 percent of county production on an energy-equivalent basis. Owners in the wet-gas counties west of here get paid partly in ethane and propane, which move on their own prices. A Belmont owner has one commodity, priced in one region, and no second leg to stand on.

Curtailment is a decision made in a marketing office
Appalachian gas sells at a discount to the national benchmark because pipeline capacity out of the basin is finite. When too much gas chases too few outlets, the regional price falls, and at some point the gas is worth more left in the ground than sold. So operators shut it in. For a mineral owner that means months of near-zero volume on a well in perfectly good health, then a recovery when winter demand returns. Nothing was lost; it was deferred.
This is not theoretical. In its third-quarter 2026 results EQT reported “Sales volume of 583 Bcfe, inclusive of 21 Bcfe of strategic curtailments” — roughly 3.5 percent of what it could have delivered, deliberately not delivered. The same release described a realized differential of $(0.64) as “favorable to guidance despite widening basis during the quarter,” crediting “marketing optimization and curtailment strategy.” EQT’s Ohio operating subsidiary is Rice Drilling D LLC, which is one of the companies reporting Belmont County volumes.
The EIA’s October 2026 Short-Term Energy Outlook forecast Henry Hub averaging $3.48 per MMBtu in 2026 and $3.16 in 2027. Belmont gas does not receive Henry Hub. It receives Henry Hub minus whatever it costs to move Appalachian gas to a buyer that month, and in shoulder season that subtraction gets ugly.
Decline and curtailment leave different fingerprints
Lay two or three years of statements side by side and track two columns: the volume allocated to your decimal, and the price per Mcf you were paid.
- Price down, volume roughly flat. A pricing problem, not a reservoir problem: regional differentials, or post-production deductions growing as a share of a smaller gross.
- Volume easing down smoothly, month after month, regardless of price. Decline. A horizontal Utica well gives up the steepest part of its curve in the first eighteen to twenty-four months, then flattens into a long, shallow tail. It does not care what gas costs.
- Volume dropping hard in a cluster of months, then returning. Curtailment. It steps rather than slopes, tends to land in spring and fall when heating demand is gone, and it reverses.
- Volume at zero and staying there. Neither. Look for a workover, a gathering line problem, a title suspense, or a well that has genuinely reached the end.
Ohio gives you a narrow but real right to ask
Most owners never use it, but Ohio Revised Code 1509.30 lets the holder of a royalty interest in a gas well request three things in writing from the well’s owner: the volume of gas they were paid for in the most recent payment period, the price per thousand cubic feet paid to them, and the volume shown to have passed through the owner’s meter for the field containing the well. The owner must supply it within fifteen days or by the end of the current payment period, whichever is later, and must keep the volume records at least two years. You can ask no more often than your payment period.
That third item is the one worth having. The field meter is gas that physically moved, and the gap between what moved and what you were paid for is where curtailment, fuel and shrinkage, and post-production deductions all live. Be realistic about the limits: this is a 1972 statute, it covers gas rather than oil, and it is not an audit right. It will not hand you the operator’s sales contracts — but it will tell you whether the gas went anywhere.

Why the distinction moves the number on an offer
Buyers almost always start from trailing cash flow: a recent stretch of your actual checks, usually the last twelve months, multiplied out and then adjusted for who operates, how far down the decline curve the wells sit, what is still undrilled, and where the gas strip is trading. There is no universal multiple. It is a range, and it moves.
The trap is mechanical. If your trailing twelve months contain curtailed months, a multiple applied to that average prices a temporary decision as though it were permanent reservoir behavior, and you get paid for a well that looks worse than it is. The opposite error costs just as much: treat a genuine decline as curtailment, wait for a recovery that never comes, and you have held a shrinking asset for nothing. Ask any buyer which months went into the number and whether they normalized for shut-in periods. One who cannot tell you is not showing their work.
What is under your acreage is not only what is producing
New units are still being formed here. Chief’s Order 2026-201, issued June 15, 2026, unitized Expand Operating LLC’s McFrederick G UP Unit, 414.361 acres in Wayne Township, for the Utica shale and Point Pleasant Formation under R.C. 1509.28. A flat check can change for reasons that have nothing to do with the well you already have.
Formation language also matters more here than almost anywhere else in Ohio, because it has been litigated here. In Tera, L.L.C. v. Rice Drilling D, L.L.C., 2024-Ohio-1945, Belmont County leases granted rights in the Marcellus and Utica while reserving other formations to the landowner. The Supreme Court of Ohio reversed and remanded, finding triable questions of fact about whether those leases reached the Point Pleasant interval and whether the drillers acted in bad faith. The Point Pleasant is where the gas is. Read your own grant; leases and mineral deeds for the county are recorded with the Belmont County Recorder in St. Clairsville.

When waiting is the better decision
If curtailment explains your soft year and you do not need the money now, a winter of normal sales gives you a cleaner trailing twelve months to sell against, which generally means a better offer. If you sit inside a newly formed unit that has not produced yet, you are holding an option — hard for buyers to price, easy for sellers to give away cheaply.
Selling makes sense when you want certainty instead of a check that swings with a regional basis you cannot control, when the wells are genuinely late in life, when an interest is split among heirs who cannot manage it jointly, or when the money does more for you now than twenty years of declining payments would. A single bad quarter caused by a marketing decision is not on that list.
Getting a number on your interest
We buy producing and non-producing minerals and royalties across eastern Ohio, and we are glad to read your statements with you and say which pattern we think it is, whether or not you end up selling. Start with our page on Belmont County mineral rights, which has a form that reaches us directly.
The same reading applies across the county line. Harrison County, Ohio mineral rights and Jefferson County mineral rights sit in the same dry-gas window and ranked second and third behind Belmont in second-quarter 2026 gas, so those owners face the same operators, the same regional discount and the same curtailment months. For the wider picture, see our guide to how to sell Ohio mineral rights, or contact us directly.
MINERAL RIGHTS & ROYALTIES
Ready to explore an offer for your mineral rights?
Tell us a little about your interest. Get a free, no-obligation review from Selling My Mineral Rights.
